Phishing simulation for SMEs: plan, run, evaluate

A phishing simulation shows how your employees react to a convincing fraudulent email before an attacker finds out. This guide explains how a small or medium-sized business plans, runs and evaluates campaigns, what a click teaches, and how reported suspicious emails are checked.

8 min read CyberTell
KAMPAGNE Q2 12.4% ↓ 72%
Key takeaways
  • A phishing simulation measures, under controlled conditions, how employees react to convincing fraudulent emails, without causing any damage.
  • Scenarios with a Swiss context and varying lures tell you more than sending the same template every time.
  • The learning moment happens right after the click: a page showing the warning signs that were missed, not a reprimand.
  • Reported suspicious emails are checked as .eml files, technically and by AI, before an incident is opened.

Why a phishing simulation makes sense for SMEs

Phishing is one of the most frequently reported forms of attack in Switzerland. In 2025, the Federal Office for Cybersecurity (BACS) recorded 12,280 phishing reports, 19% of all reports it received. Internationally, the Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report 2025 found that one in six breaches starts with phishing (16%), and a human element was involved in 60% of them.

Technical filters catch a lot, but not everything. The final decision is made in the inbox: open, click, enter data or report. A phishing simulation makes that decision visible, under controlled conditions and without harm.

A simulation is not an exam that people pass or fail. It gives you a baseline, shows which lures work in your company, and gives everyone who falls for it a concrete learning moment. It complements security awareness training; it does not replace it.

The Swiss ICT Minimum Standard also lists awareness as a measure of its own (PR.AT-1: all users are informed and trained). To see where your company stands overall, try the free ICT Minimum Standard check.

Preparation: goal, communication and technology

Goal and framework

Decide what you want to measure: the baseline, the effect of training, or susceptibility to a particular lure. Tell employees in general terms that simulations will take place over the year, without giving dates or content. Agree on the purpose and on how results will be handled with management beforehand. Anyone who falls for it should learn, not be punished.

Technical prerequisites

For the emails to arrive and clicks to be recorded, some groundwork is needed. In CyberTell it looks like this:

  • Emails are sent through an SMTP profile on your own mail server; the password is stored encrypted.
  • Clicks run through a dedicated tracking domain whose ownership you prove with a DNS TXT record.
  • CyberTell checks SPF, DKIM and DMARC for the sender domain and suggests any missing records.
  • You allow the sender domain in your mail filter so that the simulation does not end up in spam.
  • You import employees via CSV.

Realistic scenarios with a Swiss context

A simulation only works if it resembles the emails that actually arrive. The BACS semi-annual report 2025/2 shows whose names phishing sites most often abuse: postal services (24%), public transport (20%) and the financial sector (19%).

CyberTell's phishing simulations come with templates that have a Swiss context, for example:

  • a parcel notification or an expiring public transport pass
  • a phone bill or a security warning for a cloud account
  • internal senders such as management, the IT service desk, accounting or HR

You create company-specific templates in the editor or have the AI draft them. If you wish, the AI tailors the subject and text to each individual recipient. You set the sender and the form of address for each campaign, so that an email "from a colleague" sounds like one.

Vary the lures. If you only ever send parcel emails, all you end up measuring is whether employees recognise parcel emails.

Phishing Simulations Sample data
Template editor with a preview of a simulation email Template editor with a preview of a simulation email
Template editor with a preview of a simulation email

Running a campaign in five steps

In CyberTell, a wizard guides you from the template to sending. The campaign only starts once the template, sending profile, recipients and tracking domain are ready.

  1. Choose the scenario

    Pick the template and learning page, and set the sender and form of address.

  2. Set up delivery

    Choose the SMTP profile and tracking domain. The check shows whether SPF and DMARC are in order.

  3. Select recipients

    Pick employees freely from the list, individuals or the whole company.

  4. Set the schedule

    Define the start time and sending window, and spread delivery so that not all emails arrive at once.

  5. Review and launch

    Check the summary and release the campaign.

Phishing Simulations Sample data
Overview of phishing simulation campaigns in CyberTell Overview of phishing simulation campaigns in CyberTell
Overview of phishing simulation campaigns in CyberTell

What employees learn from a click

The most important moment in a phishing simulation is the click.

Anyone who clicks in a CyberTell campaign does not end up with a fraudster but on a learning page. It explains that this was an exercise and shows the warning signs by which the email could have been recognised. The warning signs match the lure used in the template:

  • Authority: verify supposed instructions from managers or IT through a known channel.
  • Urgency: deadlines and threats are meant to stop you thinking.
  • Fear: "account locked" pushes people into acting rashly.
  • Curiosity and reward: unexpected parcels, prizes or refunds are rarely genuine.

If a replica login page follows the email, only the fact that something was entered is recorded. CyberTell does not store entered passwords.

The learning moment works best when it is short and does not embarrass anyone. It can be deepened with interactive courses on the lure in question.

Evaluating results without naming and shaming

Once emails are sent, CyberTell records four stages per recipient: delivered, opened, link clicked, data entered. The campaign report shows the open and click rates and can be exported as PDF or CSV. A separate list shows employees who clicked in several campaigns.

A few principles have proven useful when evaluating:

  • Trends, not single figures. What matters is the click rate across several campaigns with varying lures, not one value.
  • Limit access. Only administrators see results per person. An employee only sees their own learning page.
  • Targeted follow-up training. Anyone who clicks repeatedly needs support, not a reprimand.
  • Encourage reporting. The goal is not just that nobody clicks, but that suspicious emails get reported.

Regular rather than one-off

With auto programmes, CyberTell creates new waves on its own on a daily, weekly, fortnightly or monthly schedule. Each wave can go to a random selection of employees, so that not everyone receives the same email at the same time. If you want to see each wave beforehand, have it created as a draft for approval.

Phishing Simulations Sample data
Results of a campaign with the status for each recipient Results of a campaign with the status for each recipient
Results of a campaign with the status for each recipient

Analysing reported suspicious emails

A phishing simulation trains people to recognise phishing. In everyday work, the next step is reporting, and someone has to assess the reported email. That is what phishing analysis is for.

The suspicious email is saved as an .eml file with full headers and uploaded. CyberTell then checks:

  • sender authentication with SPF, DKIM and DMARC, plus sender mismatches
  • links and attachments against local blocklists, without the links leaving the platform
  • attachment metadata

On top of that comes an AI assessment with a risk score from 0 to 100 and a traceable explanation. It supports the decision; the responsible person makes it.

If the suspicion is confirmed, you open an incident directly from the result and, with a connected firewall, can block the domain. What happens next is covered in the article on incident response.

Phishing Simulations Sample data
AI assessment of a reported email with risk score and explanation AI assessment of a reported email with risk score and explanation
AI assessment of a reported email with risk score and explanation

Frequently asked questions

Do employees need to be told about a phishing simulation?
It is advisable to tell employees in general terms that phishing simulations will take place over the year, without giving dates or content. That keeps the test realistic, and nobody feels deceived. Decide beforehand who sees results per person and how they will be handled.
How often should you run a phishing simulation?
Several campaigns spread over the year, with varying lures, show more than a single test. In CyberTell you can set up auto programmes on a daily, weekly, fortnightly or monthly schedule for this.
What happens when an employee clicks the link?
They land on a learning page that explains it was an exercise and shows the email's warning signs. If a replica login page comes first, only the fact that something was entered is recorded; the password itself is not stored.
Won't the simulation emails end up in spam?
To make sure the emails are delivered, allow the sender domain in your mail filter. Emails are sent through your own mail server, and CyberTell checks SPF, DKIM and DMARC for the sender domain and suggests any missing DNS records.
How can I tell whether an email is phishing?
Look at the real sender address, where links actually lead, and signs of pressure, fear or unexpected prizes. If in doubt, ask through a second, known channel. In a company, the email can be uploaded as an .eml file to the phishing analysis, which checks headers, links and attachments and provides an AI assessment with an explanation.
Topics